TPG Readers Weigh In: Which Premium Card Would You Choose?

Jan 7, 2018

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

We’ve compared the perks and protections across premium credit cards to attempt to see which comes out on top, but really the best pick for you depends on what benefits you value the most. If you’re going to pay $450 (or more) a year for a card, it better be giving you bonus points where you spend the most and deliver you valuable extras like annual travel credits you can use and access to a chain of airport lounges that you frequent.

So let’s see which cards fit the bill for readers. Here’s where alliances were drawn when we asked you to pick one premium card above all the rest over in the TPG Lounge. (Some comments have been lightly edited for clarity.)

Chase Sapphire Reserve

Image courtesy Hyatt
Transfer Ultimate Rewards points earned with the CSR to partners like Hyatt. Image courtesy of the Grand Hyatt Baha Mar.

“Chase Sapphire Reserve for the win! Best earn rates and transfer partners. I just spent a week in the Bahamas at the Grand Hyatt Baha Mar all with Chase UR points — it would have cost $5,300 but it just cost 120,000 points and didn’t spend a dime of my own!” — Rob M.

“Chase Sapphire Reserve is my favorite card. I love that the $300 annual statement credit for travel includes parking garages, toll roads, taxis and Uber and Lyft, in addition to airline and hotel charges. I love transferring Ultimate Rewards points earned on my Chase Sapphire Preferred Card and Chase Freedom (especially the quarterly 5x points offers of the Freedom card) to my CSR account where points are worth more when using them to reserve travel directly from the Ultimate Rewards portal.” — Ann Marie W.

“CSR. We use the Priority Pass lounge benefit every time we fly. I also filed a trip cancellation claim last month and they processed and paid out the claim without any hassle.” — Kathy R.

Citi Prestige

The Citi Prestige's 4th Night Free benefit can save you a bundle, especially at expensive properties like Amanpulo in the Philippines.
The 4th Night Free benefit can be a game-changer at ultra-expensive properties like Amanpulo. Image courtesy of the hotel.

“Citi Prestige. That 4th Night Free perk is a GAME CHANGER. I used to stay about 3 nights in a city and then move on with my itinerary, but since utilizing the Prestige card I’ve thoroughly enjoyed staying 4 nights now and slowing down some.” — Nelson M.

“I love Citi Prestige’s 4th Night Free benefit since I travel Sunday night – Thursday afternoon for work every week. My client reimburses me for all 4 nights that I paid for so I get to pocket the 4th night rebate. I get thousands of extra dollars per year that way!” — Shaina G.  

“Citi Prestige. The 4th Night Free makes me significant money back each year. Plus I love the trip protection. Not in love with the airline partners but have used points with great success on Singapore business, which is amazing.” — Lara H.

The Platinum Card® from American Express

One of the Amex Platinum’s most popular benefits is Centurion Lounge access. Image courtesy of the Centurion Lounge at PHL.

“Amex Platinum, because of the 5x points on airfare [and on hotels booked through Amex Travel] plus the automatic Gold status with Hilton, SPG and Marriott. Not to mention the lounge access!” — Danny A. 

“The Business Platinum Card® from American Express. With Delta Club, Centurion Lounge and other lounge access, a $200 annual airline fee credit and Gogo passes it pays for itself.” — Scott P. (Note that the personal version of this card only offers Boingo hotspot access.)

“American Express Platinum. Simply because they were the first one to approve me for a premium card. It works with more airlines, which I like. Also 5x the points when I book flights and hotels. I like their points offers, and their customer service has been very patient and answered all my questions even when I bombard them with questions.” — Donna V. 

Other Picks

“I’m still ecstatic with my United MileagePlus Club Card. Amazing how fast the miles pile on with this card – far more than just with actual flights. Wish I’d listened to you sooner!” — Donna P.

“Delta Reserve® Credit Card from American Express because I’m so Delta-oriented and it gets me 30,000 MQMs (so, I’m Platinum instead of Gold), free companion flight, Delta Sky Club access, MQD waiver, upgrade priority in tiebreaker situations and more.” — Hugh H.

Finally, for those of you who are curious, we tallied which cards got the most love on the TPG Lounge post and here were the results as of late afternoon on Thursday, January 4, 2017:

  • Chase Sapphire Reserve: 58 responses
  • Amex Platinum/Business Platinum: 32 responses
  • Citi Prestige: 6
  • Amex Centurion:  3
  • Delta Reserve: 1
  • United MileagePlus Club Card: 1
  • United Presidential Plus Card (no longer available): 1

Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.