How Do Pilots Take Off in a Snowstorm?
This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.
It’s that time of the year again: Deep winter in the northern hemisphere, when major airports face disruptions from snow, sleet and extreme weather. If you flew through New York-JFK last year, you might have not-so-fond memories of the bomb cyclone that shut down the biggest gateway to the United States.
If you transit through Chicago O’Hare (ORD) regularly, you know very well the pain of winter-weather delays. London Heathrow is not immune, either. Chances are you’ve found yourself on an airplane sitting on a taxiway, waiting — and waiting — as snow swirled outside. Or you’ve had your flight cancelled due to fog.
But what does that look like from the cockpit? And how exactly do airline pilots cope with tough winter weather, from snowstorms to strong winds? And what weather events, if any, do pilots fear more than others?
For the answers, we turned to an expert: a pilot who flies Boeing 787s for a major international airline and has seen all kinds of weather all over the world.
In an email, he told us all about flying in tough winter conditions. (We have omitted his name, so he could speak as freely as possible, and lightly edited for brevity and clarity.) Here’s what he had to say:
Snow Is the Worst
Different types of weather bring their own challenges. Strong winds can create bumpy conditions on the departure and approach. If the wind is across the runway, we have to fly “crabbed” into the wind to keep us tracking straight. The test of our skill comes when the aircraft is just feet above the runway. Using one of a few approved techniques, we have to straighten the nose while keeping the aircraft tracking down the centre line. Ask a pilot what their most satisfying time at work is, and most will tell you a good crosswind landing.
Fog, too, gets us thinking. When you’re hurtling down the runway at 195 miles per hour and you can only see 250 feet ahead, you need to bring your “A” game. However, rigorously practiced procedures for situations like this ensure that we keep all on board safe.
However, it’s probably snow and ice conditions that potentially provide the biggest challenge to our skills as professionals.
While you’re in a cab on your way into the airport, your pilots are also heading in, and thinking about the challenges ahead. Bad weather days require extra focus and thought.
During a pilot’s initial training, a large part of the theory is on weather and how it can affect flights. We’re taught from a very early stage to respect the weather and never to take any chances with it. Mother Nature is a powerful force.
How heavy is the snowfall? What’s the temperature? What kind of snow is it? What’s the wind doing? All these questions will be running through our heads before we even arrive at the airport.
The main threat to flight safety during snowy conditions is contamination on the flying surfaces. The design of the wings is so advanced that any snow or ice on the surface can massively affect the performance of the aircraft.
In order to create lift and climb away from the runway, the aircraft requires airflow over the wing. It’s this airflow that actually makes us fly — the engines merely create the forward motion. For every flight, the pilots calculate the speed required to lift off safely. This is based on the aircraft weight, weather and runway conditions at the time of departure. When we reach this speed, known as “Vr,” we ease back on our controls and the aircraft rotates into the air.
However, this speed is based on a “clean wing” free from any snow and ice contamination. Buildups on the flight surfaces can affect the airflow and, consequently, the lift, making the calculated Vr speed too slow — with potentially disastrous consequences.
Before every flight, one of the pilots walks round the aircraft to check its physical condition. During snowy weather, a major part of this is to see what contamination exists. The engines, wings and external sensors all come under close scrutiny. However, quite often the only way to check the upper surface of the wing is by looking out of a cabin window, so don’t be surprised if you see a pilot doing this — it’s a good sign!
From these checks, we know what kind of de-icing procedure we need to make the aircraft safe for departure. If there’s any doubt as to how bad the contamination is, we will always consider the worst case. Too much de-icing is better than too little.
De-Icing on the Cake
We want to be home with our families and friends as much as you do. However, while we are always mindful of punctuality, we are very aware that it can quite often be pulling in the opposite direction of safety. It’s our job to manage that balance.
Sitting at the gate, waiting to be de-iced, we know you have connections. We know you have meetings. We know you just want to get home. But aviation history is littered with incidents where pilots cut corners to try and save a few minutes, only to regret that decision later on.
But why does de-icing take so long?
There are two ways aircraft can be de-iced, either with the engines shut down on the gate or with engines running on a remote de-icing area. This depends on the airport and on what facilities are available. Airports that experience snow and ice conditions regularly tend to have remote de-icing facilities. Montreal Trudeau Airport (YUL) is a great example. Airports that experience these conditions only a few times a year, such as Newark Liberty International (EWR), tend to have trucks that will de-ice aircraft at the gate.
Now, I can already hear you asking why these big airports like Newark don’t just have the better facilities. It comes down to a matter of space and cost. Remote de-icing pads cost a great deal more and take up a lot of space. Would you spend thousands of dollars on a fancy electric snow-clearing device for your home when you know that for the few days a year it snows, a shovel will be just fine?
The de-icing process itself can take anywhere from a few minutes up to 30, depending on how much snow and ice there is on the aircraft. When there are only a limited number of de-icing trucks, you can see why delays build up quickly.
All this time, we remain relaxed in the flight deck. You can’t rush these things. Let the trained professionals do their job and when the de-icing is done, it’s done.
Once de-icing has been completed, the clock is ticking. If snow is still falling, it’s only a matter of time before it starts to accumulate on the wing again. This time is called the holdover time; we work out how long we have before we need to be airborne or get de-iced again. This time depends on the de-icing fluid used, the air temperature and what kind of precipitation is falling.
While there seems to be a race against time in this situation to get airborne, once again, we are the gatekeepers of safety. If the taxi to the runway takes too long and our holdover time runs out, we have to return to be de-iced again. More delays and more frustration for you, but we are doing our job: Keeping you safe.
Yes, You Can Take Off on a Snow-Covered Runway*
Once we’ve made it near the runway, our focus steps up another level. We’re listening closely to air traffic control (ATC). When we can’t see landing aircraft because of poor visibility caused by the snow, we have to build a mental picture in our heads of where other aircraft are.
It’s for this reason that ATC should always speak in English, the official language of aviation. By listening to instructions issued to other aircraft, we can tell if there is one about to land, or another taking off farther down the runway.
ATC will also give us information about the runway conditions, and this is where my asterisk comes in. You can take off on a snow covered runway … depending on how slippery it is and how much snow has accumulated.
There are different kinds of snow. It can either be quite wet or very dry. This depends mostly on the air temperature. If the snow is very dry, as it often is in areas like northern Canada and Scandinavia, there can be conditions where it’s possible to take off with visible snow on the runway. This depends on how slippery the runway is.
Most airports have special vehicles with a roller on the back that can measure just how slippery the runway is. This information is then passed to pilots who use this to work out their aircraft’s performance for take off and landing, as mentioned earlier.
However, the wetter the snow, the more slippery the runway. This is typical of snow storms on the eastern seaboard in the US, when the air temperature isn’t too cold. When the runway is slippery like this, it has to be cleared and treated with anti-ice.
Naturally, this can take time — time during which we can do very little except wait. Once again, it’s all for your safety.
When approaching the runway to take off, we are constantly assessing the weather to ensure that the performance we calculated earlier is still valid. If things have changed, we have to redo the performance calculations, which takes time.
Only when we’re happy that the aircraft is free from all snow and ice and that the performance is still valid, will we tell ATC we’re ready for departure.
When we line up on that runway with 200-plus lives on board, we want to know that we’re going to take off safely. By abiding religiously by all these procedures, we make sure you get to your destination safely — even if it’s a few hours late.
For more TPG news delivered each morning to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter here.
Featured image by Rebecca Butala How/Getty Images
Welcome to The Points Guy!