The worst 5 premium-economy cabins in the sky today

Jun 28, 2020

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

Premium economy is almost always the smallest cabin on the plane, nestled between economy and business. Because it falls in between those two in price, seating and service, people often wonder whether premium economy is worth it and what the difference between economy and premium economy is. The answer to those questions depends heavily on the airline and aircraft type.

To help clear things up, we’re doing roundups of our best and worst premium-economy experiences over the course of the past year. We already outlined our top 5. To see which airlines’ premium economy you might want to avoid, now it’s the turn of our lowest-ranking premium-economy flights (from pre-COVID times).

From cabin crew who didn’t know what food they were serving to shoddy service and subpar inflight entertainment, here are the five worst premium economies of the past year.

China Southern Airlines Boeing 777

Score: 57

The best thing about this flight was probably only the price, at $700 (£557) for a one-way ticket from New York to Jakarta, Indonesia, via Guangzhou, China.

As an avid fan of the 777, it’s safe to say that Alberto, TPG’s Special Projects Editor, was let down by China Southern’s version of the popular bird in premium economy.

Let’s start with a couple of positives. Shell-style seating can be controversial depending on the flyer, but Alberto liked how this meant that nobody could recline into him. Aside from that, slippers featured as one of the amenities — a little luxury that you don’t even find in many business class cabins.

Related: Smaller, better, lighter: The evolution of airline seating

Shell premium-economy seats on China Southern’s 777 (Photo by Alberto Riva/The Points Guy)

Everything else about this flight was well below par. The “questionable” in-flight entertainment (IFE) had a distinct lack of options for passengers who didn’t speak Chinese. The headphones were of low quality, too.

With a rating of 11 out of 25, the biggest letdown of all was the food. It was reminiscent of a something you’d be served in a school canteen rather than the kind of food you’d expect from premium economy.

In Alberto’s words, “The best thing about lunch was the big tray table I ate it on”.

The giant tray table featuring China Southern’s first meal service in premium economy (Photo by Alberto Riva/The Points Guy)

The poor-quality food went hand-in-hand with poor-quality service on this flight from New York to Guangzhou. When Alberto asked what the choices were for the second meal, the crew member responded “I don’t know” — that’s almost laugh-out-loud behaviour.

Just when you thought it couldn’t get any worse, and after two already memorable — for all the wrong reasons — meals, the third and final meal on the 15-hour flight was a tiny turkey sandwich wrapped in plastic and served with no tray or box.

China Southern’s finest turkey sandwich ‘au plastique’ (Photo by Alberto Riva/The Points Guy)

Brussels Airlines Airbus A330

Score: 60

Zach Griff, TPG Travel Analyst, is one of our most frequent flyers, so he’s had his fair share of good and bad experiences in the air. This flight with Brussels Airlines from New York to Brussels on an A330 was definitely one of his worst.

Related: Why I always board last, no matter where I’m sitting on the plane

While the cabin and seat scored nearly full marks at 26/30, the airline fell short in almost every other category, achieving only half marks for amenities and IFE, food and beverage and service.

Zach enjoyed the generous seven-inch recline and found the seats to be comfortable, more than the seats in United’s Premium Plus cabin.

(Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)

The was a distinct lack of amenities for a premium cabin, and the IFE was “lacklustre,” not ideal when you’re on a fairly long-haul trans-Atlantic flight.

Related: Watch as TPG U.K. reviews 5 different airlines on day flights from New York to London

Nothing about the meals Zach was served was “premium”, in fact, it was the exact same as what was being served in economy. The dry pasta dish didn’t taste great and was served in the usual economy-class foil tin with not a plate in sight.

(Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)
(Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)

The carb-heavy, nondescript tray of pastry and bread served for breakfast also had serious room for improvement to make this really feel like a premium meal service.

(Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)
A very carb-heavy, boring breakfast (Photo by Zach Griff/The Points Guy)

United Airlines Boeing 777

Score: 62

To say TPG’s Editor-at-Large Zach Honig flies a lot would be an understatement — in 2019 alone he racked up over 220,000 miles! Many of those miles were with United, too, so he knows what to expect from the airline’s different products. With that, it’s safe to say his flight last year from Newark to Hong Kong on one of United’s flagship 777-300ERs would certainly make the list of his least-favourite flight experiences.

From the seat to the food, pretty much everything about his flight could have been better. Zach didn’t like the “crappy headrests”, and the legrest was “ineffective”.

Premium Plus seats on United’s 777-300ER from Newark (EWR) to Hong Kong (HKG) (Photo by Zach Honig/The Points Guy)

The main issue, though, was the food and drinks service. Passengers did not get physical menus, even though in United’s Premium Plus cabin they are supposed to receive them. It was already off to a bad start.

The chicken for the main meal was “way overcooked”. Later in the flight, about mid-way to Hong Kong as most passengers were sleeping, Zach was handed a “gross” turkey and cheese sandwich along with another drink.

Premium Plus main chicken dish (Photo by Zach Honig/The Points Guy)

Breakfast wasn’t much better. While the thought of a Mexican-style ensemble of eggs, beans and tomato sauce might get the taste buds going, the entire thing was disappointingly dry. At least the food was served on actual bowls and plates.

Zach’s dried-out breakfast onboard United’s Premium Plus (Photo by Zach Honig/The Points Guy)

Alitalia Airbus A330

Score: 67

The disappointment during Alberto’s experience flying from New York to Rome on one of Alitalia’s A330s started with the decidedly disorganised boarding process. But that was no surprise given that it’s often the case with Alitalia.

One thing that Alberto did appreciate, at 6 feet 2 inches tall, was the 38 inches of legroom, as this meant that he didn’t feel too cramped and uncomfortable during his night flight across the Atlantic.

Spacious premium economy seats on Alitalia’s A330 (Photo by Alberto Riva/The Points Guy)

The low-resolution and unresponsive IFE screen coupled with the disappointing movie selection would have probably made for a very boring flight indeed had it been during the day. Not all hope was lost, though, as Alberto discovered that the selection of music was to his taste, and the BBC World and CNN live channels worked without a glitch.

On the whole, the meals on this flight were “undistinguishable from coach-class fare”. There were, however, a couple of saving graces: passengers had a choice of either blood-orange juice, prosecco or water during boarding and, perhaps best of all, real espresso coffee was served at breakfast.

The “filling and unforgettable” main meal in Alitalia’s premium economy (Photo by Alberto Riva/The Points Guy)

Austrian Airlines Boeing 767

Score: 72

The fifth cabin in this roundup should actually have been Air Canada Rouge’s Boeing 767, which the airline recently removed from service, so we had to substitute for it the next-lowest scoring, which was intern Javi Rodriguez’ flight from Vienna to Washington, D.C. with Austrian, also on a 767. While 72 isn’t a particularly bad score by any means, and is just a bit below the 73-point average for long-haul premium-economy, it’s clear from Javi’s experience that there is room for improvement in a couple of areas.

As per the rating of 22/25, Javi was happy with the hard product overall. There was nothing wrong with the seat or small 18-seater premium-economy cabin; the seats were comfortable with ample 38-inch pitch, shoulder space and storage including bottle holder. For an old bird, the upholstering of the seats seemed fresh and clean.

(Photo by Javier Rodriguez / The Points Guy)
Some of the seats onboard Austrian’s 767 in premium economy (Photo by Javier Rodriguez / The Points Guy)

In terms of pitfalls, a major issue for Javi was the lack of Wi-Fi, which none of the airline’s long-haul aircraft feature.

Javi only scored 15/25 for food and beverage. He described the main meal of the first food service as only “decent”, as the chicken was dry — often an issue with inflight catering. Despite Austrian being well-known for its extensive coffee offering in biz, the same cannot be said for premium economy, as Javi was also only served the same bog-standard aeroplane coffee as economy passengers for his post-meal pick-me-up.

The real problem was with the “borderline inedbile” meal that he was served before landing which consisted of gnocchi swimming in oil.

(Photo by Javier Rodriguez / The Points Guy)
The “borderline inedible” gnocchi that Javi was served for his second meal (Photo by Javier Rodriguez / The Points Guy)

And finally, the service lacked a premium spark that you might expect when paying a considerable amount more to fly in premium economy rather than economy.

Bottom line

It isn’t easy to give a yes or no answer when asked “Is premium economy is worth it?” The key is to make sure you’re getting value for money by figuring out if the extra money you spend on a ticket means you’ll see a distinct improvement in seat and cabin comfort, and of course, that the food you’ll be served isn’t just the same as in economy.

Featured image by Javi Rodriguez/The Points Guy

Editorial Disclaimer: Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, airlines or hotel chain, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any of these entities.

Disclaimer: The responses below are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.